2020
- January: Son Little – Aloha
- February: Tennis – Swimmer
2019
- January: Sharon Van Etten – Remind Me Tomorrow
- February: Bob Mould – Sunshine Rock
- March: Foals – Everything Not Saved Will Be Lost – Part 1
- April: Steve Gunn – The Unseen In Between
- May: Eli “Paperboy” Reed – 99 Cent Dreams
- June: Black Pumas – Black Pumas
- July: Bailen – Thrilled to Be Here
- August: Robert Randolph and the Family Band – Brighter Days
- September: Whitney – Forever Turned Around
- October: Brittany Howard – Jaime
November: Beth Hart – War in My Mind
- December: Beck – Hyperspace
2018
January: Anderson East – Encore
February: Van William – Countries
March: Nathaniel Rateliff & The Night Sweats – Tearing at the Seams
April: Belly – Dove
- May: Family Of The Year – Goodbye Sunshine Hello Nighttime
June: Lake Street Dive – Free Yourself Up
July: Erika Wennerstrom – Sweet Unknown
August: Fantastic Negrito – Please Don’t Be Dead
September: Andy Bopp – Wherewithal
October: Kurt Vile – Bottle It In
November: Revivalists – Take Good Care
December: Adrian Quesada – Texas Soul Project